Best Burgers in West Allis – A Must-Try List for Burger Lovers
If you’re craving a juicy, flavorful burger in West Allis, you’re in luck! This city is home to some incredible burger joints—ranging from classic American diners to creative, gourmet burger spots. Whether you’re a fan of crispy patties, melty cheese, or wild toppings, West Allis has something for every burger lover.
In this guide, we’ll take you on a mouth-watering tour of the best burgers in West Allis, Wisconsin. We’ve included spots loved by locals and hidden gems you shouldn’t miss. Let’s dig in!
1. Cudahy Burger Joint – Classic with a Twist
Location: TheCudahyBurgerJoint.com
Known For: Flavor-packed gourmet burgers, loaded fries, and fresh ingredients.
Although technically in Cudahy, this burger joint is close enough to West Allis and totally worth the drive. Their handcrafted burgers come with unique toppings like garlic aioli, crispy onions, and spicy pickles. Try their “Smash Patty Burger” or “Southwest Fire Burger” for a real treat.
“Fresh, juicy, and made to perfection. One of the best burger places I’ve visited in the area!”
2. Kopp’s Frozen Custard
Location: 7631 W Layton Ave, Greenfield, WI (close to West Allis)
Known For: Big butter burgers and legendary frozen custard.
Kopp’s is a Milwaukee-area staple. Their butter burgers are simple yet rich, served on fresh buns and packed with flavor. The portions are generous, and if you’ve got room after your burger, the custard is a must.
Try the “Double Cheeseburger” or “Bacon Cheeseburger” – they’re huge and filling!
3. Oscar’s Pub & Grill
Location: 1712 W Pierce St, Milwaukee, WI (short drive from West Allis)
Known For: Gourmet burgers with unique toppings.
Oscar’s isn’t far from West Allis, and it’s often ranked among the best burger places in Milwaukee. Their menu features signature burgers like “The Big O” with hickory bacon, chipotle jack, and jalapeño sauce. Each burger is a flavor bomb.
Pro Tip: Get there early – this place fills up fast, especially on weekends.
4. Jake’s Burgers and Custard
Location: 7700 W Layton Ave, Greenfield, WI
Known For: Juicy patties and a retro diner vibe.
Jake’s delivers that classic American burger experience. From mushroom Swiss to spicy jalapeño burgers, the variety is excellent. Pair your burger with crinkle fries or onion rings for the full combo.
Family-friendly, fast service, and consistently great food!
5. Leff’s Lucky Town
Location: 7208 W State St, Wauwatosa, WI (close to West Allis)
Known For: Burgers and bar bites with a twist.
This neighborhood sports bar is known for great drinks, chill vibes, and delicious burgers. The “Lucky Burger” and “Black and Blue Burger” are crowd favorites. They also offer vegetarian options.
Grab a burger and a beer, and enjoy a game on the big screen!
6. Stack’d Burger Bar
Location: 170 S 1st St, Milwaukee, WI
Known For: Build-your-own burger and local ingredients.
If you like full control over your meal, Stack’d is for you. Choose from beef, turkey, chicken, or veggie patties, then customize with a wide range of cheeses, sauces, and toppings.
Vegans rejoice – they also have an excellent plant-based burger!
🍔 Best Burger Spots in West Allis, WI
📍 View on Google Maps
📍 View on Google Maps
📍 View on Google Maps
📍 View on Google Maps
📍 View on Google Maps
What Makes a Burger Great in West Allis?
When ranking the best burgers, we looked at:
- Flavor and quality of the meat
- Freshness of toppings and buns
- Creativity and uniqueness
- Customer reviews and local love
- Atmosphere and service
West Allis and the nearby areas do not disappoint. Whether you want a basic cheeseburger or something stacked with onion rings, bacon, and specialty sauces, you’ll find it here.
Quick Comparison Table: Top Burger Spots Near West Allis
| Restaurant | Burger Style | Price Range | Specialty |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cudahy Burger Joint | Gourmet/Smash | $$ | Southwest Fire Burger |
| Kopp’s Custard | Butter Burger | $$ | Double Cheeseburger + Custard |
| Oscar’s Pub & Grill | Gourmet/Spicy | $$ | The Big O |
| Jake’s Burgers & Custard | Classic American | $-$$ | Mushroom Swiss Burger |
| Leff’s Lucky Town | Bar Style Burger | $$ | Black & Blue Burger |
| Stack’d Burger Bar | Custom Build | $$$ | Vegan & Craft Burgers |
Local Tip: Don’t Just Eat – Explore
Many of these burger spots are located in fun neighborhoods. After your meal, explore West Allis Farmers Market, take a walk around Greenfield Park, or hit up a local bar or dessert spot. Make your burger run a full-day adventure.
Final Thoughts—Best Burger in West Allis?
The truth is – it depends on what you’re craving.
- Want a gourmet-style smash burger? Head to Cudahy Burger Joint.
- Craving a classic butter burger with a cold custard? Kopp’s is calling your name.
- Looking for unique toppings and spice? Don’t miss Oscar’s.
Whichever you choose, you’re in for a satisfying bite.
